When it comes to mental health, women are being left behind.
Mental health, an area we work on intensely, is weighing heavily on my mind.
Particularly the mental health of women.
Why women?
Because mental health is yet one more area in which we see a significant gender gap, with women twice as likely to be diagnosed with anxiety as men. That disparity is global, but it is more pronounced in certain parts of the world…
…most specifically, in socially conservative countries that are in the process of modernizing.
As is often the case, it is women who suffer the most during this transition.
A 2018 study that looked at global data for depressive disorders found a strong correlation between gender inequality and gender disparities in mental health, with women twice as likely to suffer from mental illness as men.
That finding is not a one-off. Earlier research assessing women’s status in society on the basis of political participation, economic autonomy, employment and earnings and reproductive rights found a link between lower gender equality scores and higher levels of depressive symptoms in women. In gender unequal countries, that gap widens as women age.
More socially conservative societies tend to have more pronounced gender inequalities, so it follows that women in these places have higher rates of depression and anxiety;research showsthat rigid gender norms have a negative impact on even women’s cognition in later life.
In other words, a more progressive male population means better mental health for women all around. It is in nations that are transitioning from traditionalism to modernism that women suffer the most.
The Indian example
India is a case in point.
Medix Global is very active in the mental health space in India and, during my recent trip to Mumbai and New Delhi, I had several conversations with women about their own states of mind. How they were doing depended, in large part, to what they were dealing with and to what generation they belonged.
India is hurtling toward modernism, and society is struggling to keep up.
Younger women grew up in this new world and are, in general, more at ease with its developing progressive values. They are convinced that their individual happiness should supersede old societal mores and are willing to pursue paths, both personally and professionally, that fulfill them, as opposed to only doing what their parents or society at large expects them to do. And while arranged marriage is still the norm, an increasing number of young women are actively involved in choosing their spouses, in what they call “love marriages”.
More mature, not to say older, women, on the other hand, didn’t have that freedom. Today they find themselves sandwiched between the conservative beliefs of their parents and the society they grew up in, and the more progressive views of the generation below them, that of their children.
They are stuck in between.
Like their younger counterparts, these women have realized that the modern world is about more than the traditional gender roles that have kept them confined to their domestic duties. Sadly, only about 20 percent of working-age women in India are employed outside of the home. These numbers impact not only women’s independence, wellbeing, and mental health, but also the country’s overall productivity and economy.
Struggling through modernization
The women in transitioning societies such as this one are going to go through very hard times before they can achieve anything close to the kind of gender equality that would close the mental health gender gap.
During my last trip to India, I held conversations with a variety of families from different generations, including with a 51-year-old gentleman who was married to a 44-year-old lady. They have three children together between the ages of 16 and 25. Having married in their late teens, they had recently decided to get divorced, which carries a major stigma in this socially conservative country. India has one of the lowest divorce rates in the world, with only 1 percent of marriages ending in legal rupture—though a 2016 analysis found that three times as many couples had separated without divorcing. The taboo is so strong there that most unhappy couples opt to continue to live together under the same roof with certain levels of mutual understanding and with various arrangements.
Single adult children, such as those of this couple, often want their parents to stay together, even if unhappy, because having divorced parents can hamper their own marital prospects due to the unbearable stigma that carries for them.
When it comes to their own marriages though, younger generations are learning to prioritize mental wellbeing over conservative cultural and societal expectations. During that same trip, I also met a 27-year-old lady who split from her husband after merely two years of marriage. The breakup was, of course, difficult and painful for the couple, as all divorces are, and perhaps even more so for their parents, but this woman knew she would be okay in the long run and was looking forward to starting a new chapter in her life; something the older generation of divorced women (unlike men) could simply not imagine. They felt they had failed in their lives and would never get a second chance at finding love, or even another relationship.
Despite the clear need, Indian women are less likely to seek less mental health support than women do globally. That’s partly because of the often-insurmountable shame that remains associated with mental health, and partly because the infrastructure is still poor in many parts of the country. India has only 0.7 physicians per 1000 people and only 1 psychiatrist for every 343,000 people. Access, already problematic, is likely even more of an obstacle for girls and women who, particularly in remote areas, have limited mobility, financial independence, and privacy. For them, receiving mental healthcare remains a dream.
Much can—and must—be done to drive change, and that imperative cannot be placed solely on the shoulders of the government. That social responsibility is to be shared by all stakeholders, both public and private, from schools and universities to insurers, employers, and healthcare systems. These groups must all work together to educate, to increase awareness and to develop new mental healthcare models that are especially designed for women, ranging from women’s physical community mental health clinics to digital and virtual solutions, including therapy, counseling, coaching and other means of ongoing support. These care models must be adapted to specific age groups, providing different modes of care for young girls, women until their late 30s, and for women in their 40s and above. Technology must play a pivotal role if these programs are to be scaled effectively.
As Indian society modernizes and society shifts, it is essential that we support women and their mental health in every way that we can.
No tags found. To all articles >